Photographic Review of Frank Shaving Richmond Silvertip Brush

Leave a reply

Today I am reviewing the Frank Shaving Richmond Model Silvertip Badger Shaving Brush. Weighing in at only 40 grams, this brush feels cheap. Considering the retail price, I’m not surprised. Instead of the normal resin, this handle is advertised to be made from acrylic. Feels cheap too. The “FS” logo rubbed mostly off after two uses. Thankfully, this seems to be where the majority of the corners are cut.

The knot itself is not bad. I would call the knot medium density with a high loft. The softness of the bristles is okay, but the loft is quite high for the density of the hair. Feels very much like a floppy BK4 in lathering performance. Great for creams, not so good with hard soaps or face lathering.

The closest brush in loft and density I have on hand is the Semogue 2015. The knots of the two brushes are very similar. I would give the FS brush the edge in density, but the Semogue’s handle is much better, even after several years of use.

Shown here next to a Shavemac 117, the FS doesn’t do too badly, but the Shavemac has the edge. The Shavemac is certainly a firmer brush and better all around performer.

Compared to Wet Shaving Products “Stubby”, the FS brush is sparsely packed with hair.

 

As you can see, the Frank Shaving is a medium density brush and should be compared with other medium density brushes. It certainly is not going to compete with Simpsons Super, Rooney 3 band, Plisson High Mountain White, Shavemac D01, or any other true high quality brush by any stretch of the imagination.

Update: This is apparently a new model by FS. The handle is made from Plactic, whatever that is. Poor English aside, I guess you get a little less than you pay for with FS. See his ebay sales.

This is Teiste’s take on it.

Guide to Buying Your First Straight Razor

Leave a reply

I am constantly being asked this question: Which straight razor do you recommend? I’ve been meaning to write this article for a while now, but have been busy with other projects. Well, here it is; finally.

This guide is written with the beginner or non-wet-shaver looking to buy their loved one a fantastic gift in mind. Veteran straight razor users should already know what they want, but there will still be some gems of wisdom contained herein, especially the section about purchasing a vintage razor. Whether you buy a new razor or a used razor, you should stay within a certain size and shape.

Size/Shape/Grind

The beauty of straight razors is that they come in so many different combinations of size (blade width), shape, and grind thickness. The problem with buying straight razors is sorting out which one to choose. Below are pictures depicting your options.

Razor Grinds

Razor Points

The commonly given advice to new users is to buy a 5/8″ to 6/8″ round point in hollow grind. By staying within those parameters, you cannot go wrong. However, there is much wiggle room. New straight razors do not come in spike/square points anymore. The Spanish, notch, & round points offered these days do not have the sharp tip said razors do and are perfectly fine for a beginner. The hollow grind is likewise just a suggestion. It really doesn’t matter which grind you choose, be it 1/4 hollow or a full hollow grind. One grind will not shave any better than another. The only difference is that the thicker grind will have more mass than the thinner grind. So, if you want more momentum behind your razor, go with a thicker grind, otherwise, just choose the razor that appeals to you.

Size does matter. But not that much. As long as you stay 6/8″ or under, you will be fine. In fact, some people report that they find a 4/8″ razor much easier to learn on. A 6/8″ razor is pretty large for a beginner, but not so large as to be unwieldy. A 7/8″ razor is huge. The good news is that all starter razors don’t come in such large sizes and will conform to what is universally regarded as easy to use.

To Jimp or Not to Jimp?

Jimps are small cuts in the steel that facilitate grip. They are found on the bottom or top & bottom of the tang. See the picture below. A thumb notch is another feature. It’s designed to fit your thumb. The thumb notch may or may not come with jimps.

The answer is that you should opt for jimps if available. However, you really don’t have much control over what features your razor will or will not have. Most new “beginner” razors come with bottom jimps cut into the tang.

So Which New Straight Razor Should I Buy?

The short answer is a shave ready razor that you like the look of and can afford.

Shave Ready

Let’s break that down starting with “shave ready”. Shave ready is supposed to mean a straight razor that has been sharpened to the point of being comfortable to shave with. While most people are honest about using this term and do possess the requisite skill and equipment, there are some shady sellers out there trying to increase the value of their item by using the term “shave ready.” The takeaway is to purchase your first straight razor from a verified source. Or at the very least, make sure they have a sharpness guarantee of some sort.

When evaluating a vendor, check to see who their sharpener is, what their guarantee is, and feedback from users. Also, make sure they use the exact term “shave ready” and not some derivation thereof. When in doubt, just ask them who sharpens their razors. If they give you a vague answer or say the factory does, then go elsewhere. There are plenty of vendors who don’t upcharge you for shave readiness.

Shaving forums recommend you buy from other members of the shaving forum. Most of the time, you get a good deal, sometimes you don’t. The good thing about the forum members is that they normally know what they’re doing and what shave ready means, so you are unlikely to get a bum product. The problem with the forums is that you have to be a member and you’re buying a used product. Nothing wrong with either, but some people care.

As an alternative, you can always take a gamble and if it’s not up to your standards, send it to us for sharpening.

Aesthetics

This comes down to purely personal preference. I cannot tell you which razor looks better because my opinion is ultimately subjective. However, I can tell you that the Dovo Best features plastic scales and the fit & finish is not as good as the Bergischer Lowe. Same with the basic Thiers Issard razor found at Art of Shaving. The base model comes with plastic scales and their high end models come with natural horn or wood scales, gold wash, and a better overall finish. The old adage, “you get what you pay for” is exactly right.

If aesthetics is important to you, you probably don’t want to buy a Dovo Best and should save up your money to buy at least the Dovo Special. If you go with the cheaper model, you may just regret it for a long time. These razors are not disposable after all. You will be stuck with your choice until you can afford to replace it.

Cost

Which brings us to cost. Of course cost is important. Your first straight razor should not strain your finances. While I said above that buying a cheaper razor might not be a good idea in the long term, you don’t know yet whether you want to stick with straight razor shaving. As such, you should budget accordingly. While it is true that you may be able to sell a razor for close to what you paid for it, that isn’t always the case and will depend on who you sell it to. In reality, you’re probably just going to have to eat a good portion of the cost.

Put differently: if you are absolutely sure you will stick with straight razor shaving for life, save up and splurge. If you are not so sure or just want to try straight razor shaving, save your money and buy the cheapest functional razor possible. We offer this shave ready straight razor for less than what you will be able to find elsewhere.

Which Vintage Razor Should I Buy?

Buying a vintage razor has many advantages over buying a new razor. The most obvious is the price, followed by the quality of the manufacturing. Old razors have survived for decades or centuries because they were someone’s prized possession. This translates into good steel. While modern razors are getting better, the best razors cost a good amount of cash. Without a doubt, if you know what you are looking for, vintage razors can represent the best value for your dollar.

The problem with buying a vintage razor is that you could be buying a lemon. There’s also so many to choose from it will make your head spin.

Echoing what I have already said above, the #1 factor you need to look for is shave readiness. As such, who the seller is, is of paramount importance. Only buy from a reputable merchant or someone you trust. There are plenty of junk vintage razors out there.

If you choose to buy a restored razor, most of the pitfalls of buying vintage razors are already taken care of for you. The only choice you need to make is who to buy from. We restore our razors through a minimum of sanding in order to keep the original lines and shape of the razor. Other restorers will sand the razor to remove every single imperfection, making for a very shiny razor, but losing the original lines. See below for examples of each.

Click here to visit our gallery of work for ideas. Neither approach is wrong. You just need to choose which is right for you. Also keep in mind that the more labor that goes into a restoration, the more expensive it is. So, if you see restoration work for less than the going rate, you should make sure they don’t use a tumbler rather than a buffer or cut other corners.

This razor has been buffed and sanded a lot – the original grind lines are gone

This razor has been through our less intense restoration process

The Point

Many vintage razors come with a square point. Probably because it is easy to manufacture. Whatever the reason, the beginner is left with a pointy object that isn’t very forgiving. The very tip can be chamfered, making it much more user friendly. All other razor points do not have that issue and would be very well suited for a beginner. But don’t let the “spike” point deter you from a razor you otherwise like. It can be chamfered and it will behave similar to a round point.

What to Watch Out For

We now come to the meat of the guide. Sadly, many vintage straight razors are either too used, damaged, or rusted. The following guide will help you avoid some of the most common pitfalls.

Damage & Rust

Unless the razor has a huge chunk of steel missing, the first thing you are going to notice on a vintage razor is either the absence or presence of rust. Rust is not necessarily a deal breaker and it is usually present, but it’s not good. If the razor is completely rust free, it’s a good buy, but will cost more.

If the razor has chips, cracks, or is damaged in some way, don’t buy it, or get a professional opinion as to how much and the feasibility of dealing with the damage.

If the razor has rust present, you have to look at the edge. If the rust is pervasive along the edge, stay away. If the rust is only on the top of the razor, but not on the edge, the razor should be fine, but you want to have a professional inspect the piece to make sure the steel is still good. If you do end up wanting to purchase a razor with rust, keep in mind that rust is a signifier of pits. While we can remove the rust and minimize small pits, we cannot remove large pits without regrinding the razor. See the pictures below for some guidance.

Don’t buy this razor!!!

This razor can be restored

The other thing you want to look at is the scales. Are the scales broken anywhere? Do they have bug bites? Are pieces missing? If the scales look to be in good shape, then check to see if the pivot point is still tight. That is easily fixed by tapping lightly on the pin until the scales tighten up. However, there is a small risk of damage with really old razors and some materials. Look for rust inside the pivot point. If there is a lot of rust, you may want to stay away from the razor.

Razor Near the End of Life

While their lifespan is several generations if proper care is taken care of them, straight razors do not last forever and their lifespan can be significantly shortened by misuse. If you encounter a razor that has excessive hone wear on the spine, don’t buy it. It is that much closer to being thrown away. For some more examples of excessive wear, check out our previous post on common honing mistakes.

Another indicator of end of life is a really skinny razor. Most people sharpened their razors with the spine flat against the stone. However, some people lifted the spine and hone the razor like a knife. Today, people use tape and disguise any hone wear (not intentionally). Not normally a problem, but it is something that may be a problem.

If in doubt, pass.

In Conclusion

Vintage razors are generally excellent razors, but there are lemons out there. While they represent a better value over a new razor, you run some risks unless you purchase from a trusted restorer. New razors are, well, new. They also cost more and may not shave as well as some of the great vintage razors available. However, good values can be found. We do sell both new and vintage razors.

When choosing what you want your razor to look like, it is up to you. As long as you stay under a 6/8″ blade, you cannot make a bad choice. Just be sure to have that spike point tamed so you don’t accidentally stab yourself.

Cocobolo Scales Joseph Rogers

Leave a reply

Fromm Straight Razor Review

Leave a reply

My review of Fromm’s offering to new straight razor users can be summed up in two words: “Why bother?”

But, it’s made in Germany, so it must be good right?

No. The “made in Germany” mark is not regulated. The European Union only requires that the final manufacturing step be performed in the country of origin.

But, what about all my German cutlery? It’s very good stuff!

Of course. But it’s marked “Made in Solingen”. The Solingen brand is highly regulated. Quoting from Solingenmade.com:

  • during all the key manufacturing stages have been processed and finished within the industrial boundaries of Solingen (which, for these purposes, includes not just Solingen but also the neighbouring town of Haan)  and,
  • in terms of their raw materials and manufacture, be suitable for the purpose for which products of that type are made. This means that even cutlery which is manufactured within Solingen’s town boundary is not entitled to bear the name Solingen if it does not conform to the required quality standards

fromm-2

Now, don’t get me wrong, these razors are generally well made and fully functional. However, they come from the factory very dull. You can’t even make the argument that it is possible to shave with these razors out of the box. Unlike Dovo (whose razors are always sharp, but sometimes hit or miss as to shave ready sharp), Fromm razors are not shave ready sharp out of the box. So, unless you sharpen it yourself, that is another $15-20 to tack onto the total price. So, points are deducted for that.

And let’s not forget that this razor is $60!!!

fromm-1

The Master Grind

Let’s talk about the grind. Having had a few dozen pass through my hands, the grind is…worse than a Gold Dollar 208. And that is not a very rousing endorsement of this razor, to say the least. The master grind is the only grinding that really matters. The master grind is the actual hollowing out of the faces of the razor. If the grind is off or the razor warped, you end up with a knife rather than a razor. Unfortunately, the master grind is not as consistent as Dovo (which is not known for being 100% great) and of lower consistency than Gold Dollar 208, 300, 800/200. Yes, a $15 razor has a better master grind than a $60 razor.

You can see the poor master grind as revealed by the uneven spine wear

You can see more evidence of Fromm’s grinding issues in the customer photos in this amazon listing.

Here's another example

Here’s another example

Same razor different face

Same razor different face

Fit & Finish

Moving on to the fit & finish of the razor, the Fromm actually does quite well. Compared to a Dovo Best, the Fromm holds its own quite well. The finish of the blade is even and the satin-like finish is even. The shoulder bolsters are ground evenly. The tang is blued. The polish is decent. The scales are plastic, but what do you expect for $65. Even the razor coffin is pretty attractive.

The scales are mediocre. They’re made from flimsy ABS plastic and don’t even have the decency of having a third pin to help stiffen the scales. But, they work.

fromm-5

Steel Quality

Sadly, although the Fromm straight razor looks decent, it’s all form, and not much substance. The steel the factory uses is not as good as Dovo steel nor is it as good as the alloy used by Gold Dollar. I would classify the steel as adequate. Nothing to write home about, but it’s not defective either. It takes an edge and holds it well enough, but you can buy better. You can even buy better for less money.

In conclusion, I cannot recommend this razor. They are competing with Dovo at a lower price point, but offers a much lower quality product. While it may look pretty, it doesn’t deliver in performance. You are better off spending the extra $10. Factoring in the cost of sharpening this razor, and you aren’t saving anything by choosing a Fromm razor.

There’s a reason I don’t carry the Fromm razor. I most certainly could stock it. The wholesale price is quite good. But the blade is bad. Save your money and move up to a Dovo, down to a Gold Dollar 208, or horizontally to a Gold Dollar 800. You’ll be much happier. I’d throw in a GD300, but the scales are… purple.

Where Shaving Brush Badger Hair Comes From

Leave a reply

 

Badgers are wild animals. They are extremely vicious as well. They have not been domesticated, nor have any serious attempts been made. Badgers are a vermin and a pest in China. They are protected in the UK and many parts of Europe.

Nearly all badger hair is sourced from trappers in China. The prevailing method of hunting is to gas the badger sett. The entire animal is used. The pelts are sold to fur traders and the meat is sold for food in poor areas. Both the Eurasian Badger (Meles Meles)* and the Hog (Manchurian) Badger (Arctonyx Collaris) are harvested. The top three grades of badger hair are harvested from the Eurasian Badger. Two-band Finest and black badger hair come from the Hog Badger.

A pictorial on available badger brush hair grades.

The pelts are then graded by the distributor and sold to knot manufacturers. Side note: These manufacturers either sell only knots or make whole brushes (either outsourcing the handle or also making them in-house like Edwin Jagger). The knot maker then removes the hair from the pelt and sorts the hair into the different grades of hair they sell.

Once the hair has been sorted by grade, the maker gathers the right amount of hair (by weight) and combs the hairs to remove any stray hairs and align the hairs properly. The hairs are then placed into a mold which gives the bulb the distinctive shape. The bottoms of the hairs are then tapped until all the tips are at the top. The knot is then bound with thread and the bottoms of the hairs cut off according to the desired loft. Finally, the plug is glued to the bottom to keep the knot in shape and the thread removed. Pictures of the process can be found here.

At this point, you may still be wondering where each grade of badger hair comes from. Silvertip is harvested from the white areas around the neck of the Eurasian Badger. A lower quality (slightly greyer) hair often called best or super is harvested from the lighter bands down the sides of the animal. Grey badger hair comes from the center of the back. Two-band finest badger hair is from the light areas of the Hog Badger. Black Badger hair comes from the large black areas of the Hog Badger. The lowest grade of badger hair consists of the castoffs.

China has regulated badger seasons and protected reserves where hunters may not harvest badgers. However, in the north, the Meles badger is considered a pest and more or less runs rampant. Also, in the rura areas, the government influence does not extend to all areas of life and so poaching may be common.

Badgers change their hair during the seasons. They grow a thick winter coat and shedding it come spring time. The Hog Badger lives in the tropical south and so may not shed its hair like its northern brethren. Since the point of trapping badgers is to harvest the hair for money, it is unlikely that the eurasian badger is trapped at all during the summer or early fall months.

Picture of Eurasian Badger Pelt.

Information courtesy of Wet Shaving Products – Makers of Fine Brushes for the Discerning Gentleman.

*There is a debate as to whether the Meles species consists of three distinct sub species. M. meles, M. Leucurs, & M. anakuma. China & some scholars believe they are all Meles meles. Some people disagree. The meles family has a large range that extends from Europe to Asia.


George Wostenholm Pipe Razor Restore

Leave a reply

Restored John Barber 1700’s Straight Razor in Original Ivory Scales

1 Reply

This razor is from around the 1700’s. It is the oldest razor I’ve ever seen in person. The gorgeous ivory scales have survived through the centuries. This razor was given a facelift to bring it back into the 21st century.